Standing Up for Choice
Donnie Darko is one of the more memorable movie I have seen in a long time. While certainly not the best nor the most coherent film, it nevertheless had quite an impact on me. At times darkly funny while at others just downright eerie, Donnie Darko is a twisted little piece of film-making. It features two of the creepiest characters in recent memory- thanks to a demonic bunny suit and an unorthodox turn by Patrick Swayze- not to mention a mind bend of a story blending high school angst, time travel, a jet engine falling from the sky and an amazing 80s soundtrack. Let’s just say it’s a pretty difficult film to categorize- and judging by the online debates surrounding this modern cult classic, it’s also safe to say that it’s a pretty difficult film to follow. Even after several viewings, many- including myself -are still not entirely sure what it is even about. Yes, it is the sort of movie that your self-important film snob friends will deem a brilliant masterpiece based largely on the fact that it is confusing.
Donnie Darko is one of those movies that leaves itself wide open to interpretation. Is it about the search for God? Is about acute psychosis? Is it a cautionary tale against wearing giant rabbit suits on Halloween? To be honest, I’m still not too sure myself, even years after first viewing the film on a pirated DVD back in China. What I do believe, however, is that a central theme in Donnie Darko is the dissection of destiny. In this regard, it asks a very profound question: If you are made aware of your destiny, can you consciously choose to follow it or not…or was it pre-destined that you would choose to follow that path, hence making it your destiny to begin with? Pretty convoluted, I know. But give yourself a few minutes to think about it, and soon enough you will be twisted in your own metaphysical knot. What came first, the destiny or the choice?
This film, I believe, is so intriguing precisely because it taps into these age-old questions of humanity. Like the rest of us, it wants to know: how much agency do we really have over the course of our own lives? Are we destined to follow certain paths, or rather are we making it all up as we go along? Does fate exist, or it just a more romantic word for chance and statistical probability?
These questions, among others, have been bouncing around my mind a fair bit as of late, as I find my life in yet another transition period. Who doesn’t love the legendary transition periods? Usually following the end of academic studies, employment, a relationship or a sojourn abroad (or, if you are really unlucky, several of them simultaneously), they are those lovely times when all that was once solid melts into air. While dreaded for their inherent bouts of aimlessness, angst and possible temporary returns to the parental fold, they can nevertheless be understood in a positive light. Being in a transition period is a precious chance, if you are lucky enough, to pause the movie of life and think: What do I want to do with myself? What sort of career am I really suited for? How can I best make use of my experience and qualifications? Where do I want to live? I fight to remain positive in my transition periods because I realize that, unlike the huge majority of people, I can afford to stop and ask these questions. Instead of just barreling along, I get to make explicit choices. And this is certainly not something I should take for granted.
Choices, of course, are not always easy. They can be scary. They can have uncertain outcomes. They can go wrong, leading to pain and regret. Perhaps it is for these reasons that so many of us are so often afraid of choice; it is because we are afraid to take responsibility for our own decisions and their consequences. Rather, we prefer to hide behind ideas of destiny and fate. How many times have you heard someone tell you something “was meant to be” or “wasn’t meant to be?” Sure, these are just expressions, but they betray our underlying desire to dump agency on some unseen force, absolving ourselves of responsibility for what took place, especially if we did something potentially wrong.
But, in the end, I don’t believe I am pre-destined to be in any particular career or place, or be with any particular person. I could “wait for something to come along”; I could wait around to somehow meet “the love of my life”; I could believe that “somehow everything will work itself out”. But after twenty-five years, I have come to the realization that this is the coward’s way out; this is how to avoid making the tough decisions. Of course it is easier, and more comforting, to think that fate is guiding you- and yet, will this spectator’s view of your own life really get you anywhere? Should you really rely on some metaphysical invention to make you successful and happy?
I say no. I say boycott the ideas of destiny and fate, those refuges of the weak-minded, the indecisive and the lazy. I say it’s time we accepted that, above all, we are responsible for our own actions, and thus the path down which we guide our lives. I say make your choice and take responsibility instead of blaming the stars or a situation. In the end, something is “meant to be” or “not meant to be” depending on what is chosen to be. Ultimately, expecting fate to make your choices for you does not a happy life make. Get that Disney nonsense out of your head, and take the bull by the horns.
March 12th, 2006 at 11:27 pm
I like the way you think.
And Donnie Darko is indeed an awesome movie, although I’ve never seen it for sale in China. (Where did you find it??)
March 13th, 2006 at 9:31 am
John,
I think I found it in an electronics market in good ol’ Zibo, Shandong way back in early 2003. Surprisingly, the selection there was much better than in Hangzhou- one of the other foreign teachers got friendly with the guy who supplied the whole market’s DVDs, and the rest of us benefited. We always got to go to the ‘back room’ and sort through through all the fresh movies still packed in their shipping boxes from Guangdong.
Or maybe it was in Jinan around the same period- there was a place in that city where you had to crawl up into a mini-attic where the roof was seriously LOW (and if at 6 foot and a bit I had trouble, well I’m sure it would have been a contortionary delight for you!). But you could sit in there for hours on a couch and sort through box after box of just about the randomest movies you can imagine.
Moral of the story? Shandong had some sweet DVD connections.
March 17th, 2006 at 1:27 am
Nice. I’m sure if I put forth the effort I could get some sweet Shanghai DVD connections, but I really don’t watch so many DVDs these days…
March 21st, 2006 at 7:57 am
Interestingly, if you get a version with the commentary, and watch it, the director is pretty clear that Donnie Darko is a “superhero” and points out several parts of the movie where this is shown. I was not sure if I agreed with this or not, but he is the director….
Also Jake Gyllenhaal (sp?) sounds exceptionally immature on the commentary, which is annoying.
In Beijing any of the DVD shops opposite the North Gate of the Lido Complex have it.