Travel Journal: 河南 (Henan)
Friday, July 30th, 2004The train ride from Xi’an to Zhengzhou was rather uneventful, our mostly empty soft seat car giving us a little bit of welcome breathing space. My mom and I sat watching the countryside go by, eating yogurt ordered from one of the train attendants (my mom had fallen hard for “Chinese” style yogurt, and she almost got me hooked).
The train trip was a great lesson in how varied the country’s landscape can be. No need to cross huge distances and brave the deserts; crossing from eastern Sha’anxi into western Henan, the scenery changed quite a bit.
For the first while out of Xi’an, the scene changed little: arid villages and brick factories interspersed with dried-up riverbeds and eroded land. Elderly people carried heavy loads along dirt paths, their barefoot grandchildren in tow.
Then came some canyons with a good number of cave dwellings. Next time I looked out the window I was surprised to see huge mountains right up against the train, not a trace of humanity in sight. This rugged landscape slowly gave way to some lush green farmland, looking quite mysterious in the misty rain that had descended upon it.
This picturesque place could hardly last, however. The number of towns and villages soon increased as we moved into Henan, their muddy roads and garbage-strewn streams soon taking over the vista. Infrastructure was definitely not this area’s strong point. Massive coal power stations soon began to appear on the horizon, welcoming us with a thick haze. My mom and I were a bit shocked by the number (and size!) of power stations under construction, their scaffolded smokestacks eager to join their sulphur-belching friends.
By the time we were passing Luoyang, any trace of countryside calm had given way to a sprawl of decaying industry supported by miles of faceless concrete apartment complexes. The rain and haze probably made it appear more depressing than it was, but I remember at that moment wondering why we had chosen to visit Henan (something I was to repeatedly ponder over the next few days).
Zhengzhou was as faceless as only interior Chinese provincial capitals can be. Absolutely massive, the city had the requisite white-tile skyscrapers, billboard-smothered concrete bunker malls and snarling traffic at street level. The only thing of note was an oddly-proportioned Mao statue completely overshadowed by the spaghetti junction twirling around it. Ummm, urban planning anyone?
Scenic Zhengzhou
There was nothing at all remarkable about the place apart from its incredible blandness. In Zhengzhou I had a realization: I was no longer just fascinated with cities being “Chinese”.
If that sounds a little odd, let me explain. Previously, I had found any Chinese city to be fascinating, what with their high energy and bustle. They were different, exotic- this was China. However, as I gradually got used to it all, the mystique wore off. I once again became able to tell whether a city was great or, well, a shithole.
Zhengzhou was a dump.
Regardless, my mom and I set up shop in the Holiday Inn (travelling with a middle-aged parent has some very tangible perks). I felt like I was in some strange bubble consisting of an immaculate hotel room, BBC International and some crazy Japanese networks. The Chinese restaurant felt lifted right out of a North American Chinatown (well, besides the pleather man purse crowd happily smoking the place into oblivion).
Originally, we had planned to use Zhengzhou as a base of sorts for day trips to Luoyang and Kaifeng. But at some point we decided a good chunk of our Henan time would be better spent escaping to Shandong, so Kaifeng was the only place of note we ended up visiting.
So on a horrible rainy day, we set out to find the east bus station to catch a quick ride to Kaifeng. The Holiday Inn was on an avenue that was imposing for no other reason than to be, well, imposing. As we made our way along, we took in the usual faux-palace government buildings, their drives smattered with the usual black sedans. The philosophy in these parts seemed to be: “if it is going to be tasteless, at least make it big”. But unlike Xi’an, the grand scale here seemed almost farcical. My mom summed it up perfectly: “All this show, but what for, really? There’s nothing here.” Sprawl for its own sake is not pretty.
Due to my stubbornness, we missed the bus station and instead ended up walking under a highway interchange on our way to getting all turned around. On one side of us were Audis dealers; on the other was a destitute scene of mud, earth piles and vagrants. As blue trucks rumbled overhead and the air was at its foulest, I once again had to wonder: what were we doing in Henan?
Finding a bus station splattered with mud and sporting some sketchy looking people, we got on our bus and waited (at this point my feet were thoroughly soaked through). I looked around and thought the bus station scene belonged more in some far flung rural backwater than a major city.
An hour later (or I guess I should say an hour after our bus finally left), we arrived at our destination. Kaifeng was the saving grace of our brief stay in Henan. Although the rain was still coming down and the mud was still omnipresent, something about this town was quiet and soothing. Maybe it was because of the horrible weather or the time of year, but as tourists we seemed to have the place completely to ourselves. The lakes, parks and pagodas all sat shrouded in a quiet mist (and I mean a genuine mist unrelated to industrial emissions). The whole place just had a very laidback feel to it. One lake in particular rivalled Hangzhou’s crown jewel in the “misty mystique” department.
Central Kaifeng
One of the market streets
Pensive China: parks, pagodas and lakes
We wandered around for a few hours, enjoying the calm and entertaining a vendor by showing him a book written in English (he thought it was hilarious to see something not written in Chinese, a really friendly guy). I really enjoyed the architecture but was a bit disconcerted by the poverty that surrounded the touristy avenues.
Gone fishin’
Rooftops in the mist
Our bus ride back to Zhengzhou in the evening skipped the expressway in favour of a pedal-to-the-medal cruise on a local road. You always hear about how many millions of people live in the Chinese countryside; for the first time, I actually saw ridiculously overcrowded rural areas. The landscape looked completely strained by the human crush. For an hour or so we ploughed through a market of mud and trash, it was just never-ending people. The weather didn’t help things much.
And what was the local government doing to try and alleviate this desperate scene? Why, building monuments to themselves of course, complete with faux-Roman columns, and filling the parking lots with expensive black sedans. No wonder the boys in Beijing are so exasperated.
As our bus to Jinan braved the morning traffic, I was glad to be leaving Zhengzhou and Henan Province. The sun had finally come out, only to prove that the sky was just as grey without a storm cloud in sight (unfortunately, the rain was to eventually chase us all the way to Beijing).
My experience of Henan was muddy, dirty, overcrowded with people and underpopulated with interesting things to do (except Kaifeng). The people in Zhengzhou just didn’t come across as friendly or happy. The men seemed to be either gangsters or the long-haired migrant youth clad in dirty army fatigues and howling “haaalllos” at the moon. The weather didn’t help things much.
Memories of Henan
More Memories of Henan
An AIDS epidemic is just about the last thing this place needs.




